User talk:Billhuey

From RTwiki
Revision as of 09:14, 27 March 2008 by Billhuey (Talk | contribs)

Jump to: navigation, search

Grand Unified Scheduler Project + QoS

Questions I'm pondering:

EDF = earliest deadline first

HRT = hard real time
SRT = soft real time
BE = best effort



Can be used (1) as a hard real time policy, but also be (2) used as a way of getting minimal lag to service a burt of events like interrupts.

SCHED_RR: Cyclic/periodic in nature.


  1. How does a static priority system like Linux express itself in terms of an EDF scheduler ? This potentially complicated because of non-standard real time uses of real time policies. How do things like hardness in a SCHED_FIFO task map to in EDF ? How does SCHED_RR map onto EDF ? For a special performance driven BE burst case of use of SCHED_FIFO, a lagging or differing is not considered a failure, how is that mapped onto EDF ? This isn't considered a failure for this use the policy.
  2. Is M-CASH, EDF-HSB etc... flexible enough as an abstract container or common factor mathematically or algorithmically so that all three stock scheduler policies, SCHED_FIFO, SCHED_RR and SCHED_OTHER (CFS) can be constructed in terms of that algorithm ?
  3. How would a practical EDF system look like with overload code ? Have EDF be largely run queue localized with manual assignments and with crude not-so-rigorous aperiodic overload handling (below) ?
  4. If these algorithms overlook the problem of aperiodic overloads, then what kind of crude not so rigorous overload handling can we do ? apply what we have already with the current rt-overload logic where we scan run queues across the system (or possibly with a specific CPU set) to migrate a task to another CPU that isn't running a real time task (SCHED_FIFO/RR) ? What about the use of a cheaply precomputed slack span that can be quickly read during a cross processor run queue scan for finding a suitable BE slot span to handle an overload migration with near future soft deadline ? Let's call this EDF overload (rebalancing).
  5. How cheap is it to compute or pre-compute a span of slack slots for BE threads like irq-threads ?

Do we need EDF for QoS ? Or should we just used special manually tuned IO handling daemon servers to issue requests in terms of bandwidth ?


Personal tools